Learning to fly involves study of the weather - in particular rain and fog. A successful flight includes planning the route from your origin to your destination, having enough gas, and the willingness to change your plans but not to compromise your safety.
The rain approached Haddonfield yesterday in a way that betrayed a low-pressure system overtaking high-pressure. The gentle but constant force of the low pressure system moves moisture on top of the cap of high-pressure and gently slides it away. The rain begins slowly and accumulates as one system takes over another. Ultimately, the rain and low-pressure yeild to another high-pressure system that returns us to cleansed air and bountiful sunshine.
Governor Christie's message yesterday was essentially that it was raining pretty hard in New Jersey, figuratively, when he was elected. His election itself resembled the slowly accumulating force of discontent with Trenton and the inability of prior Governor's to stabilize the State's finances. On this, his 83rd town hall meeting since his election, I woke up the next day to the cleansed air of a public meeting where the elected official spoke bluntly and passionately about what he believes and his conviction to move New Jersey forward.
Yes, I voted for Christie in the last election. That is not what this blog is about. It is more about style than substance; and style is what Haddonfield could use a bit more of.
After speaking for less time than I expected about his legislative priorities, Christie turned the program over to Q&A (Questions and Answers). He put forward four rules, three of which we observe in our Commission meetings here in Haddonfield.
First, don't shout out, raise your hand and I will call on you. Second, wait for the mic and state your name and where you are from. Third, ignore the feeling of elation you get from holding the mic and focus on your question, not the speech you have prepared. Fourth, "We're all from New Jersey" meaning if you are going to give it then you are going to get it back.
The fourth rule of Christie's Town Hall is mitigated in Haddonfield by the ordinance which allows the Commissioners to essentially censor anyone who they believe is not communicating in a civil manner. The ordinance allows the police to eject anyone from a meeting at the direction of the Commissioners and has been wagged at the public on at least one occasion that I have witnessed by our Mayor.
I believe this has a chilling effect on dialog. No, I don't want to see chaos at public forums, but I do know that some people seeking cures for injustices may be a bit agitated or emotional at times. Our elected leaders may not have as thick skin as Christie does (I think they do) but surely they can preside over a much smaller meeting without the need for legal enforcement of good manners. Maybe the thought of calling a constituent an idiot and seeing the headline in the paper is too big a price to pay. Let's get this law off of our books.
Like any politician, Christie acknowledged that there was more work to be done, especially in the next 18 days. I'll plug his call to lean on Lou Greenwald to move forward with tax relief for State residents. Many states are pushing for reduced income tax rates to remain competitive in employment. He also acknowledged the failure of urban public schools despite the massive funding allocated to them, as well as the transfer of wealth away from Haddonfield based on the Supreme Court Abbott decision.
What really struck me was his response, however, to the last question of the day. A local merchant stood up and stated that she ran a small business in town. First to arrive and last to leave, she was continually bombarded with taxes, insurance, licenses, and regulation. "Everything I sell in my shop is recycled" she stated. But if she wanted to sell a bag of peanuts to a customer, every March she has to send in her "litter control fee" to the State. "Every March when I send in the fee I write you a letter" she told the Governor, but she had never heard back.
Christie was as amused as he was incensed. Having earlier declared that the Trenton Bridge slogan "Trenton Makes, the World Takes" referred to the fact that Trenton makes 'stupid ideas' and 'forces towns and cities around the state to impose them' on the public, he nailed that fact that this 'litter control fee' was instituted in the 2003-2004 time frame and shook his head over the whole McGreevey era.
He then directed his Director of Constituent Affairs to exchange contacts with the merchant and looked almost gleeful about the prospect of abolishing one more nonsensical regulation that he had never heard of before. With that he ended the meeting with a personal tale of conviction and his mission which is a legacy of his parents (his Mom's) dying declaration to him in the hospital of "Go to work Christopher. There's nothing you can do and there is nothing unsaid between us".
A few months back when the BID hosted an open forum I was one of the few non-merchants to attend. Guy Elzey excoriated the Executive Director of the BID for being ineffective. The owner of "The Running Store" made it clear that his success was driven by his own efforts while subsidies were handed to restaurants that routinely failed, or worse, failed and refused to pay back the loan.
When asked for a practical business strategy of promoting and maintaining the downtown area, the BID board seemed to appear as deer do in the proverbial headlights, often passing the buck (no pun intended) to the Boro and disclaiming responsibility for the appearance of downtown. By now it is readily apparent that BID funds are directed primarily at King's Highway while other commercial entities rely on their own devices.
The contrast between Christie's eagerness to fix what is wrong with the seeming intransigence or inability of the BID to quantify success, adhere to its' mission, and respond to the entire business district is like day and night, or more to the point, like sunshine and rain.
The BID needs a destination. Something other than the Mayor's response to me during the original passage that "We'll know in five years if the BID has been successful or not". It has the financial fuel to reach its destination, but lacks the engine of full support of the merchants and landlords, as well as the Boro Commissioners. And while not compromising its mission, it should surely change its flight plan and at least evaluate the ability of its pilot and crew to accomplish the mission.
I saw the Mayor and Commissioner Kasko at the event yesterday. If Commissioner Borden was not in attendance perhaps the other two can pass the message along to him.
Bill Tourtellotte
8:35 am on Thursday, June 14, 2012
For those who missed this interesting event, it can be viewed or simply listened to in its entirety at Haddonfieldcivic.com. You can scroll past portions of less interest to you, but the majority of it is quite compelling.
Dan Tompkins
10:25 am on Friday, June 15, 2012
Another point of view: "So the elephant in the room with Christie was all about money. It’s not just that he would attack Abbott funding to poor school districts to help lower property taxes elsewhere, or that he would veto a minimum wage hike. He would also be willing to roll the dice and worse on keeping public higher education affordable and competitive by damaging Rutgers beyond repair while bringing little to Rowan worthy of its elevated research status. That’s not the mark of a comeback. That’s old-time Jersey deal-making." From Haddonfield resident Howard Gillette,
http://gillette.rutgers.edu/
-- Dan Tompkins
Herb Hess
11:17 am on Friday, June 15, 2012
Dan,
I agree with you that the Rutgers Rowan merger is wrong-headed and needs to be stopped. Yes, the question of the day is money, but it is not about why Christie would cut funding to the Abbott Districts. It is about why the State Supreme Court forces the majority of funding to continue to flow to the 31 districts which fail to provide an adequate education in the first place. Surely there is a way to educate students more successfully in Newark, Camden, etc. at rates that reach or exceed $25,000 per pupil than the method we have now.
We have a systemic problem in this country where we don't prepare young people for work. Raising the minimum wage sounds nice but discourages hiring. A recent headline stated that 7 of 10 teens would not succeed in finding employment this summer. Every beach town and resort I visit each summer is staffed with Eastern European teens. Every employer I speak to does not want to hire American youth.
Perhaps you care to fact-check one of Gov. Christie's assertions, that Newark pays 100 teachers NOT to teach because they would do more harm than good, yet can not fire these teachers? Or that out of over 125,000 teachers in the State, only 17 were found to be unfit to teach and removed through the tenure process?
Dan, you are a reasoned thinker and offer great insights, especially your posts on HaddonfieldTalks about Rutgers. Unfortunately, this is not about deal-making, it is about rebuilding society in a sustainable manner.
Dan Tompkins
11:27 am on Friday, June 15, 2012
Thanks, Herb. My main concern here is: what sense does it make to push an incredibly expensive demotion of a Rutgers branch, without ANY public analysis of the cost. The is the opposite of due diligence and should be offensive to all of us, including members of the business community.
Every business transaction I've been involved in began with, "We'll have to do the numbers.". Now the numbers involve our tax dollars, and folks are giving the gov a free ride.
What business sense does that make?
Dan
Walter Weidenbacher
3:02 pm on Friday, June 15, 2012
Herb makes a great point. Seems to me that the "legal enforcement of good manners" is like mandating Charity: it ultimately stifles Charity. And, hasn't our robust guv demonstrated that in encountering bad manners, a politician gets opportunity to reveal an important facet of his/her competence? Like, as Christie says, good teachers don't need union protection, similarly, our commissioners don't really need the protection of this law.
Walter Weidenbacher
walter@temple.com
Walter Weidenbacher
3:05 pm on Friday, June 15, 2012
Ha! That's walter@temple.edu - nothing Freudian about auto completion.
Bumpkin
4:10 pm on Friday, June 15, 2012
A couple of things were very telling at the Christie event. The audacious absence of Ed Borden and the school board's behavior.
The Governor of the State in which you are an elected official is coming to your town and you don't find a way to be there?!?!? Borden's behavior is pretty consistently bad (just read his dopey defense of the turf project http://sj.sunne.ws/2012/06/14/haddonfield-commissioner-ed-borden-defends-turf-decision/ ), but to abstain from attending the event when your Governor is in town, SHAME, SHAME, SHAME!!! I guess his puppet-master George told him not to be there. After his performance (lack of) at the meeting last night we should be drawing up impeachment petitions.
Secondly, the half dozen members of the Board of Education who were in attendance sat on their hands for the entire 2 hour event. I watched closely and not one of them applauded anything he said. Is this some kind of passive-aggressive way of protesting his appearance and policies?
This silly little town is so full of itself and the nonsense that goes on daily is ridiculous!
Herb Hess
4:32 pm on Friday, June 15, 2012
People of all stripes were there. I was just as surprised by his absence as you.
You know, being a native New Jerseyan myself, I can appreciate that Christie wants to do something good for the State. I've made myself available in the past for the Library Board and generally self-volunteer to do things like snow removal around the school and school crossings, etc. We all try to make this town better.
I suggested at the Borough Budget Advisory Committee over two years ago that we bond for and complete 7 years of road program immediately, while oil was $40/barrel and interest rates were near 0% as well as inflation. Commissioner Borden did not see the merit in the idea.
Now inflation is 3%+ (if you believe that, it is really higher), interest rates are still low, and oil has DROPPED to $83/barrel. Oh, did I mention that asphalt is 80% oil.
How much more would we have been able to do given that the raw materials were on sale for 50% off or more?
If we focused on the basics a bit more we would be much better off.
Herb Hess
4:37 pm on Friday, June 15, 2012
BTW, the BOE should be very grateful to Gov. Christie. With no State laws demanding fiscal discipline and teacher financial participation in benefits, not only would wages have risen considerably more, but the local district (as Christie pointed out) would be on the hook for an additional $400,000 annually in health benefits.
This town complains loudly about State Aid. Christie laid out the argument clearly. Change the Supreme Court and we'll have a shot at interpreting the Constitution of New Jersey properly. As long as we are mandated into funding a failed system most districts will be deprived of funds they rightfully should have. Other solutions make more sense for failed school districts than spending $25K or more per year per pupil.