Chief 'Disappointed' by Ruling in K-9 Schultz Case

Gloucester Township Police Chief W. Harry Earle questions a judge's decision to grant Schultz's accused killer a stint in drug rehab.

Gloucester Township police are none too happy a Washington Township man charged with robbing a Blackwood Chinese restaurant and killing a police dog in late November 2010 apparently won't be heading to prison.

"I think it's fair to say it's certainly disappointing given the nature of the crime," Police Chief W. Harry Earle said Friday afternoon.

The Camden County Prosecutor's Office announced Thursday that Superior Court Judge Thomas Brown granted Skyler Robinson's request to enter drug rehabilitation rather than go to trial and face a prison sentence.

Robinson, 22, of Washington Township's Sewell section, was indicted in June 2011 on two counts of injury to law-enforcement animals and single counts of robbery, conspiracy to commit robbery, aggravated assault, and resisting arrest. Those charges stem from the Nov. 30, 2010, Lucky Dragon Chinese restaurant robbery and Gloucester Township Police K-9 Schultz's death on Route 42.

Robinson appears to have been able to avoid a trial thanks to a new state law that took effect just last weekend.

The new law, which was adopted by the Legislature July 19, 2012, and took effect this past Saturday, allows offenders charged with second-degree or lesser crimes to apply for entry into the diversionary drug program. It also removed prosecutors' ability to oppose such requests, placing the decision solely with judges.

Robinson must enter a guilty plea in order to be accepted into the drug rehab program.

"There's obviously a time and a place for rehab, but we're dealing with the death of a law-enforcement officer and also a violent robbery of human beings," Earle said.

While they disagree with Brown's decision, Earle acknowledged he and other police officers have learned they aren't always going to be happy with the outcomes of cases they've worked.

Gloucester Township Police Cpl. Mark Pickard, who was Schultz's handler, is among those taking this particular decision very hard.

"He was disappointed, as well," Earle said, noting Pickard had been mentally preparing himself for Robinson's trial to begin next week.

Pickard could not be reached for comment Friday.

As of 5 p.m. Friday, Patch readers had posted 60 comments to Thursday's article reporting Robinson's case had been turned over to drug court. Most readers were critical of the new law and the judge's decision, with one user calling it "a smack in the face to our Law Enforcement Community."

Earle indicated he had read some of the Patch readers' comments.

"I think everyone wants some type of explanation" on why Brown granted Robinson's request, he said.

Evan Scotese is probably among those who would like an explanation.

The 21-year-old Sewell man is serving a six-year prison sentence as Robinson's co-conspirator in the Chinese restaurant robbery. Scotese pleaded guilty to second-degree robbery in August 2011.

Earle addressed the fact one man accused of the Lucky Dragon robbery is serving a six-year prison sentence while another accused of the same robbery and an additional crime is going to drug rehab.

"It does seem inconsistent," he said.

Police responding to the Blackwood Chinese restaurant the night of Nov. 30, 2010, on a report of a robbery ended up pursuing the suspects to Route 42.

K-9 Schultz caught up to and latched onto Robinson, police said, and both were struck by a passing car. After the police dog engaged Robinson a second time, the Sewell man reportedly tossed the 3 1/2-year-old German shepherd into oncoming traffic, and Schultz was struck by at least three more cars.

Schultz died at the scene. The police dog's death led to an outpouring of support for the Police Department.

Pamela January 28, 2013 at 03:38 AM
If this is the same Judge Brown, which I will be checking into, this seems to be his M.O.. I was with a family that came before this judge, I sat in court with them, and this judge, again if same, talked the defendant into going into a facility for sex offenders, rather than prison. The defendant plead guilty to 7 counts of sexual abuse to a nine year old girl, a time spanning over a month. He wanted to go to prison, saying "G-d will cure him", the judge literally talked him into going to this skape-goat facility. The entire courtroom was shocked, including the prosecutor. I will come back to let this site know if it was the same judge, if so, I think we have a problem!
Big Daddy 1 January 28, 2013 at 05:15 AM
Pamela we do have a problem and it ain't just judge brown.
Maryann Campling January 30, 2013 at 02:17 AM
I understand that this piece of garbage is once again a guest of the County.....seems he got locked up again because of an outstanding warrant from a 2010 incident. What a surprise, huh? Don't know all of the details, perhaps Patch staff could check it out.
path January 30, 2013 at 12:09 PM
All who are upset about this verdict email the governor and appropriate authorities to protest this judgement. This is wrong and it is about time the people push the issues in this country. This piece of crap robbed a store and killed a police officer.
path January 30, 2013 at 12:10 PM
The laws in this country need to be updated and people need to pay for the crimes. You cannot rehabilitate crap, it just doesn't work, this SOB's lawyers worked the system. But the Judge ultimately made the decision. This is a travesty.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »